Author: Théophile Niyitegeka

  • Greek court blocks extradition of Turkey coup suspects

    {Turkish military officers, sought by Ankara over July’s failed coup, fled to Greece in helicopter and requested asylum.}

    Athens, Greece – Greece’s Supreme Court has ruled against extraditing eight Turkish air force officers, in a decision likely to complicate relations between the two countries.

    “It is a great victory for European values, for Greek justice,” said the claimants’ lawyer, Christos Mylonopoulos, after the ruling on Thursday.

    “The legal thinking is obvious. It is the observation of European values, the observation of legality, and the conservation of judicial civilisation.”

    Turkey said it would review its ties with Athens in light of the ruling.

    “We will carry out a comprehensive evaluation of the impact of this decision – which we believe has been taken with a political motive – on our bilateral ties, cooperation in the fight against terrorism and on other bilateral and regional issues,” a Turkish foreign ministry statement said.

    Turkish authorities want the officers to stand trial for their alleged involvement in the coup last July, which nearly toppled the government, and issued arrest warrants for the eight men in an apparent response to the ruling.

    They stand accused of attempting to dissolve the constitution, overthrow parliament, placing civilian human life at risk and stealing army materiel.

    The eight have been in police custody since landing at Alexandroupoli airport in a Turkish army helicopter on July 16. The court set all of them free, but it wasn’t clear when that freedom would take effect.

    The group had sat petrified in court before the decision, but as the first rulings were read out, they began to smile and nod in acknowledgment.

    “We didn’t escape the war. We just saved our lives, and waiting has changed our lives,” one officer later told Al Jazeera on condition of anonymity.

    He said that he and his colleagues made up their minds to escape after Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan called on his supporters to rise up against the coup, leading to clashes with troops and bloodshed.

    “From our iPads we saw what was happening,” said the officer. “We couldn’t reach our commanders. We waited six or seven hours.”

    Turkey has dismissed an estimated 100,000 people from public sector jobs on suspicion of political affiliations hostile to the ruling AKP Party. An estimated 36,000 have been arrested on suspicion of collusion in the July 16 coup attempt.

    “The arguments were that first of all they were in danger to undergo inhuman and degrading treatment. The reintroduction of the death penalty in Turkey was an additional danger,” Mylonopoulos told Al Jazeera.

    {{A tall order}}

    The request for extradition was always a difficult proposition because of the thickness of the legal requirements.

    Turkey is a signatory to the European Treaty on Extradition, which forbids extradition for political or military crimes, and gave Greece the right to refuse extradition if the crimes are punishable by death. Erdogan has said that he may hold a referendum on the return of capital punishment.

    Under the European Convention on Human Rights, which Greece has ratified, the officers are deemed to be refugees if they are at risk of torture, execution or inhumane treatment or serious bodily harm in Turkey. Also under Article 6 of the Convention, they may not be extradited for legal process unless they are assured of a fair trial.

    Partly on these legal and humanitarian grounds, three Supreme Court criminal prosecutors have in the past weeks come down against extradition. All outside legal opinions the court has heard have also come down against it.

    The decision is final and cannot be overturned by the Greek government. Asked if this raises the possibility of more Turkish nationals fleeing what they fear is political persecution, Mylonopoulos said: “The circumstances under which these people came here were very eloquent. It was very obvious that their prosecution was due to political reasons. This does not mean that everybody who has a problem with Turkish authorities can come to Greece to find a shelter.”

    The officers have applied for asylum in Greece, a process likely to take months. Asked what they want to do now, one officer replied: “We would like for none of all this to have happened. We would like to go home and be with our families.”

    The officers deny having taken part in the putsch and claim their lives are in danger
  • TV host Aamir Liaquat banned over ‘hate speech’

    {Media regulator bans popular TV personality Aamir Liaquat after he accuses abducted activists of blasphemy.}

    Pakistan’s media regulator has banned one of the country’s most popular television talk show hosts over “hate speech” and “incitement to violence”, according to a statement, after he hosted a series of shows accusing five abducted activists and their supporters of blasphemy.

    The Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (PEMRA) banned Aamir Liaquat from appearing on his network Bol TV for an indefinite period on Thursday, until the body’s complaints unit issues a final verdict.

    Liaquat is one of Pakistan’s most popular television personalities, having previously hosted a religion-themed show, as well as a major gameshow. He did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

    In the past week, Liaquat levelled a series of accusations of blasphemy against five activists who were abducted within days of each other earlier this month, accusing them of insulting Islam and its prophet, and of running anti-military Facebook pages.

    He also accused those calling for the release of the activists of supporting blasphemy, as he called out some activists by name while flashing their pictures on screen.

    Blasphemy charges

    Insulting the Prophet Muhammad carries a mandatory death sentence in Pakistan, while other forms of “blasphemy” carry sentences ranging from a fine to life imprisonment.

    There is also a significant risk of mob violence in blasphemy cases in Pakistan, where the matter is considered particularly sensitive.

    At least 68 people have been murdered over blasphemy allegations since 1990, according to an Al Jazeera tally.

    A right-wing group attacked at least one rally calling for the release of the abducted activists in the last week.

    Activists say allegations of blasphemy are aimed at silencing dissent.

    “Aamir Liaquat … has willfully and repeatedly made statements and allegations which [are] tantamount to hate speech,” said PEMRA.

    The regulator added that Liaquat’s accusations of people being “anti-state and anti-Islam” constituted “incitement to violence against citizens”.

    Liaquat has been banned from appearing on Bol TV and from declaring anyone an “infidel” or a “traitor” on any other television news channel, the statement said.

    PEMRA said it made the ruling in response to hundreds of hate speech complaints.

    “I am not in favour of banning speech, but this was not just speech. This was the only kind of speech that should be criminalised, because this is incitement to violence,” said rights activist Gul Bukhari. “Incitement to violence in the Pakistani context is different, because vigilantes can and do come and kill you here.”

    READ MORE: Pakistan delays Asia Bibi blasphemy appeal

    Jibran Nasir, an activist who was repeatedly accused by Liaquat of supporting blasphemy, welcomed the decision, saying he has also registered a legal case against Liaquat under Pakistan’s anti-terrorism laws.

    “Clearly there were many Pakistanis who felt extremely distressed, and I’m glad that that good sense has prevailed among the masses to identify someone who was spreading hate speech,” he told Al Jazeera.

    “In the end it is the constitution that prevails, which provides everyone [with] the right to dignity, freedom of expression [and] also safety, liberty and protection from harm,” said media analyst Adnan Rehmat.

    “In the presence of these clear guidelines on what is permissible and what is not, the insidious, incendiary, wanton and deliberate campaign by Aamir Liaquat was in violation of the constitution and the PEMRA laws,” he said.

    Pakistan’s media regulator, which is connected to the government, has in recent months taken a more active approach in imposing a code of conduct on the country’s vibrant electronic news media, which consists of more than 45 24-hour news television channels.

    Media rights activists and senior journalists have pushed, however, for self-regulation, fearing a crackdown on dissent by the state.

    “We are all advocating not for a ban of any channel or individuals, but for self regulation,” said Owais Tohid, a senior journalist. “The media should hold itself accountable and implement its own code of conduct.”

    Liaquat also accused those calling for the release of the activists of supporting blasphemy
  • Senior management team of US State Department resigns

    {Four leading department officials and country’s border police chief quit posts under Donald Trump’s administration.}

    An entire senior management team of the US State Deparment has resigned under the new adminstration of President Donald Trump, local media has reported.

    Four leading US officials from the State Department, which advises the US president and leads the country in foreign policy issues, left their posts on Wednesday, but the reason for the walkout has not been confirmed, the Washington Post said .

    Patrick Kennedy, the department’s undersecretary for management; Joyce Anne Barr, assistant secretary of state for administration; Michele Bond, the assistant secretary of state for consular affairs; and Gentry Smith, director of the office of foreign missions, resigned unexpectedly, the US newspaper reported on Thursday.

    According to the Reuters news agency, Undersecretary of State for Arms Control and International Security Thomas Countryman will also leave his post by Friday.

    Turnover is the rule, rather than the exception, among the top officials in the US government when the White House changes hands from one party to another, in this case from Democrat Barack Obama to Republican Donald Trump.

    A week ago, Trump’s nominee for Secretary of State, former Exxon Mobil Corp chairman Rex Tillerson, was confirmed by the Senate foreign relations committee. He has yet to be confirmed by the full Senate.

    In a separate development, the US Border Patrol Chief Mark Morgan, a former longtime FBI agent, has left the agency, a source familiar with his departure told the Reuters news agency on Thursday. The reason for his departure was not immediately clear.

    The resignations came soon after Trump signed an order for a controversial wall on the border with Mexico. He has also in his first week of office signed orders restricting visas and immigration from countries including Somalia, Sudan, Iran, Yemen and Iraq, and the entry of refugees.

    Reports of State Department resignations came as Trump's order for wall on the Mexico border caused a rift with President Enrique Pena Nieto
  • Taraneh Alidoosti boycotting Oscars over Trump visa ban

    {Taraneh Alidoosti will not attend Academy Awards whether or not US President Trump’s ban includes cultural events.}

    The Iranian star of Oscar-nominated film “The Salesman” said on Thursday she would boycott the awards in protest at President Donald Trump’s “racist” ban on immigrants from Muslim-majority nations.

    “Trump’s visa ban for Iranians is racist. Whether this will include a cultural event or not, I won’t attend the #AcademyAwards 2017 in protest,” tweeted Taraneh Alidoosti, the film’s 33-year-old lead actress.

    Trump is reportedly poised to stop visas for travellers from seven Muslim countries, including Iran, for 30 days.

    He told ABC News on Wednesday that his plan was not a “Muslim ban”, but targeted countries that “have tremendous terror”.

    “The Salesman”, directed by acclaimed Iranian filmmaker Asghar Farhadi is nominated for best foreign language film at the Academy Awards, which take place next month.

    Farhadi won an Oscar in 2012 for his film “A Separation”.

    Visa applications from Iraq, Syria, Iran, Sudan, Libya, Somalia and Yemen are all expected to be stopped for a month under a draft executive order published in the Washington Post and New York Times.

    The draft order also seeks to suspend the US refugee programme for four months as officials draw up a list of low risk countries.

    The Oscars are due to take place on February 26.

    Taraneh Alidoosti poses on the red carpet ahead at the Cannes Film Festiva
  • EU looks to fund camps in Africa to cut immigration

    {Controversial plan aims to screen asylum seekers in North Africa and return “economic migrants” to their home countries.}

    EU interior ministers have pushed ahead with plans to finance camps in Africa, where the UN refugee agency and aid groups would process people to prevent them from trying to cross the Mediterranean to Europe.

    Thomas de Maiziere, German interior minister, said on Thursday that the idea was to send the people to a safe place without bringing them into Europe.

    “The people taken up by the smugglers need to be saved and brought to a safe place, but then from this safe place outside Europe we would bring into Europe only those who require protection,” he said in the Maltese capital Valletta where the EU ministers were debating the possible ways to end the crisis.

    The sea crossing from Libya to Italy, operated by people smugglers, is the main route for those seeking better lives in Europe, but the EU wants to shut it down and admit only those they consider to be “genuine refugees”.

    Most of those taking the Libya-Italy route are regarded as “economic migrants” – those looking for jobs and not shelter from prosecution – with no chance of winning asylum in the EU.

    The camps in Libya or its neighbours would be run by the UN refugee agency UNHCR or the International Organization for Migration (IOM), which would screen the people and help return those not eligible for asylum to their home countries.

    More than 4,500 people are known to have drowned last year alone trying to make the crossing.

    {{Criticism}}

    The idea of financing camps in Africa enjoys wide political backing in the EU, but poses legal and security challenges.

    Libya sank into chaos following the 2011 overthrow of Muammar Gaddafi, and the new UN-backed government in Tripoli exercises no control over its territory.

    Such lawlessness means returning people to Libya would likely violate international law, which prohibits sending people back to a place where their lives could be in danger.

    A group of leftist European lawmakers criticised the plan, saying it was inhumane, cynical and unacceptable.

    “Even more refugees will be locked up in North Africa under high risk of torture, rape and other forms of ill treatment,” said German MEP Cornelia Ernst.

    The idea of financing camps in Africa enjoys wide political backing in the EU
  • Cameroon shuts down internet in English-speaking areas

    {Government orders internet blackout after protests against what activists call marginalisation of English-speakers.}

    English-speaking regions of Cameroon have now been without the internet for more than a week after Anglophone teachers, lawyers and students went on strike over alleged bias in favour of Francophones.

    Wednesday marks the eighth day since the authorities ordered the country’s telecommunications providers to shut off internet connections to the regions of Northwest and Southwest.

    Al Jazeera contacted Communications Minister Issa Tchiroma Bakary, the country’s minister of communications, who pledged to comment on the situation but he has yet to do so.

    The internet blackout came after the government outlawed at least two Anglophone groups – Southern Cameroons National Council and the Cameroon Anglophone Civil Society Consortium – and arrested some of their leaders.

    The groups had been pushing for so-called Ghost Town actions, in which they urge members of the public to stay at home and shops and businesses to shut.

    The aim is to peacefully protest against what activists call the marginalisation of the English-speaking regions by government imposing the French language on their schools and courts.

    The towns of Bamenda, Yuku, Nkambe and Buea came to a standstill on January 9, according to pictures and videos posted online.

    Using hashtag Bring-Back-Our-Internet, many on social media expressed their outrage at the government’s response to the protest.

    Protests in the Anglophone regions have been going on for years, but intensified late last year when protests turned violent.

    Anglophone teachers, lawyers and students have been on strike since early December with many urging peaceful protests to call for the establishment of a two-state federation.

    On Monday, Cameroonian President Paul Biya reportedly signed a decree establishing the National Commission of Bilingualism and Multiculturalism in the country.

    Activists, however, rejected the measure saying their strikes and protests are about more than language.

    The discontent

    Areas controlled by Britain and France joined to form Cameroon after the colonial powers withdrew in the 1960s.

    As a result, the country now has 10 semi-autonomous administrative regions; eight are Francophone, while the Northwest and Southwest regions are home to approximately five million English-speakers.

    Anglophones in the country have long complained that they face discrimination, saying that they are excluded from state jobs as a result of their limited French language skills.

    They also complain that official documents are often only published in French, even though English is also an official language.

    There are issues in the judicial sector as well.

    The country’s legal system is largely based on French civil law, but English-speaking regions still operate under the English common law.

    Cameroonian lawyers say that the government is sending French-educated civil law judges who do not understand English common law to their courts.

    Anglophone Cameroonians believe that only a complete overhaul of the administrative departments in the country and an inclusive federal constitution can end their woes.

    Cameroon had adopted a federal government system in the 1960s but this system was later dropped after a referendum.

    Protests in Anglophone regions turned violent late last year
  • Niger Delta villagers lose UK court bid to sue Shell over pollution

    {A British court has blocked Nigerian villagers’ attempt to sue oil giant Shell for allegedly polluting their fishing waters and farmland.}

    The two communities in the Niger Delta – the Ogale and Bille – claim decades of oil spills have ruined their homes.

    They wanted their case heard in the UK.

    But the High Court in London agreed with the Anglo-Dutch company’s argument that the case, affecting more than 40,000 people, should be heard by local courts in Nigeria.

    The villagers have repeatedly said they will not get a fair hearing in Nigeria.

    However, Igo Weli, a spokesman for the multinational’s subsidiary, the Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria (SPDC), told the BBC it was a “myth” that the communities could not get justice in their home country while welcoming the High Court decision as “common sense”.

    “It’s about claims by Nigerians about the operations of a Nigerian company in Nigeria and I think the Nigerian court is the best place to handle that,” he said.

    “It’s about incidents related to sabotage, illegal refining and crude thefts. Bille and Ogale are two communities that have been severely impacted by those activities which is a major source of pollution in the Niger Delta.”

    But neither of the communities – who say repeated spills since 1989 have meant they do not have clean drinking water, farmland or rivers – are ready to give up.

    King Emere Godwin Bebe Okpabi, ruler of the Ogale, said: “Our community is disappointed but not discouraged by this judgement.

    “This decision has to be appealed, not just for Ogale but for many other people in the Niger Delta who will be shut out if this decision is allowed to stand.

    “Shell is simply being asked to clean up its oil and to compensate the communities it has devastated.”

    They have been given the go-ahead by Mr Justice Fraser to challenge his ruling in the Court of Appeal.

    In 2014, another community in the delta, Bodo, took Shell to court in the UK over an oil spill. That case was settled by Shell the following year with an unprecedented $84m (£55m) payout to the Bodo community.

    The difference with this latest case is that the Nigerian subsidiary SPDC has refused to submit to a UK jurisdiction.

    The two communities want to pursue Shell for compensation in London
  • Buchi Emecheta: Nigerian author who championed girls dies aged 72

    {Nigerian author Buchi Emecheta, whose works included The Joys of Motherhood, Second-Class Citizen and The Bride Price, has died at her home in London at the age of 72.}

    Emecheta’s books were on the national curricula of several African countries.
    She was known for championing women and girls in her writing, though famously rejected description as a feminist.

    “I work toward the liberation of women but I’m not feminist. I’m just a woman,” she said.

    The topics she covered in her writing included child marriage, life as a single mother, abuse of women and racism in the UK and elsewhere.

    “Black women all over the world should re-unite and re-examine the way history has portrayed us,” she said.

    The president of the Association of Nigerian Authors, Denja Abdullahi, said: “We have lost a rare gem in this field. Her works would forever live to speak for her.

    “It is a sad loss to our circle. She was known for championing the female gender and we would forever miss her.”

    Lagos-born Emecheta had moved to the UK in 1960, working as a librarian and becoming a student at London University, where she read sociology. She later worked as a community worker in London for several years.

    She left her husband when he refused to read her first novel and burnt the manuscript, a World Service series on women writers reported.

    The book, In the Ditch, was eventually published in 1972. That and Second-Class Citizen, which followed in 1974, were fictionalised portraits of a young Nigerian woman struggling to bring up children in London.

    Later, she wrote about civil conflict in Nigeria and the experience of motherhood in a changing Ibo society.

    An assessment of her writing, published by the British Council, says: “The female protagonists of Emecheta’s fiction challenge the masculinist assumption that they should be defined as domestic properties whose value resides in their ability to bear children and in their willingness to remain confined at home.

    “Initiative and determination become the distinguishing marks of Emecheta’s women. They are resourceful and turn adverse conditions into their triumph.”

    "I work toward the liberation of women but I'm not feminist. I'm just a woman."
  • DRC settles one election conflict but is thrown into another

    {Political rivals fall out over choice of prime minister before poll agreed under peace deal}

    For months, it was a battle for the presidency that threatened to plunge the Democratic Republic of Congo back into conflict. Now, just weeks after a surprise political deal that pulled the country back from the brink, a power struggle has erupted over who will be the next prime minister.

    High quality global journalism requires investment. Please share this article with others using the link below, do not cut & paste the article. See our T&Cs and Copyright Policy for more detail. Email ftsales.support@ft.com to buy additional rights.

    If successful, the vote would mark the country’s first democratic transition of power since independence in 1960. But squabbles between Mr Kabila and the opposition over the selection of a prime minister are undermining the deal even before it is implemented.

    “What’s going on shows an implosion is inevitable because the [political] system is not set up to solve problems like these,” said Hans Hoebeke, an analyst at the International Crisis Group. “We’re not there yet, and in the past negotiations in Congo have taken a year longer than planned. But the signs are worrying.”

    Catholic bishops who brokered the agreement and secured Mr Kabila’s pledge to step down when the elections are held warned at the weekend that “every day of delay makes it harder to achieve our goal”.

    “The establishment of a national unity government is more than urgent,” they said in a statement.

    Under the constitution, Mr Kabila, who has led the DRC since the assassination his father, former president Laurent Kabila, in 2001, was supposed to relinquish power when his second elected term ended on December 19. But his insistence on remaining in office sparked a series of deadly protests in which dozens of people were killed. Further unrest was predicted before the bishops managed to broker the unexpected accord.

    The parties agreed that Mr Kabila would retain power, with the opposition to nominate the prime minister of a new interim government that would organise elections by the end of the year. The president would then step down. The deal was seen as a breakthrough in the large, mineral-rich country that has been blighted by years of conflict and instability.

    But three weeks later, little progress has been made. Not only are the two sides split on how the prime minister should be appointed, they cannot agree on how the electoral commission should be restructured, let alone set a timetable for the polls.

    The opposition has nominated Felix Tshisekedi, son of Etienne Tshisekedi, a veteran politician, for the premiership, while the government insists five candidates should be put forward.

    Neither Mr Kabila nor Samy Badibanga, his prime minister, has signed the accord.

    Furthermore, promised freedoms have yet to materialise. Many political prisoners remain in custody, Radio France International is among media that are still barred and the activities of human rights groups is severely restricted.

    Both sides blame each other for the stalemate.

    Andre-Alain Atundu Liongo, a government negotiator, issued a statement last week accusing the opposition of wanting to “create a fractious atmosphere of crisis . . . to realise their plan of chaos and to establish an alternative regime”.

    Abraham Luakabuanga, an opposition spokesman, said Mr Kabila’s administration was not committed to achieving a deal.

    “They want to keep all the main ministries [in the new government] for themselves — justice, defence, the interior and finance,” he said. “This is nonsense.”

    Jason Stearns, director of the Congo Research Group at New York University, said an election this year was “very unlikely”.

    “There’s a good chance it will happen in 2018 because everyone’s legitimacy is based on holding elections sooner rather than later,” he said. “But that’s not guaranteed and if it doesn’t the country is in deep trouble because the current fragile consensus will break up.”

    Neighbouring countries appear increasingly concerned.

    Denis Sassou Nguesso, president of the Republic of Congo, told the bishops on a visit to Kinshasa last week they were “the last bulwark” for peace and like “a dam that must not yield”.

    Angola, once a close ally of Mr Kabila, has started distancing itself from the president, while reminding him to abide by the deal.

    International pressure was crucial in securing the accord. Mr Stearns believes it will be equally important to prevent the process collapsing amid concerns that Mr Kabila has little intention of leaving office unless pushed.

    “His game plan is to play for time and hope that something will turn up,” Mr Stearns said. “His problem is he doesn’t know what that something will be.”

    Police fire flares at demonstrators in Goma, a city in the east of the Democratic Republic of Congo in September.
  • Burundi army major killed as violence persists

    {A military official says an army major has been shot and killed by a colleague in a remote area of Burundi.}

    Army spokesman Col. Gaspard Baratuza says in a statement that the alleged killer of Maj. Dieudonne Karashira has been arrested and is under interrogation. He has no information on the possible motive behind the Wednesday night attack.

    This is the latest incident in nearly two years of political violence sparked by President Pierre Nkurunziza’s decision to extend his rule beyond two terms.

    Karashira was attached to Cankuzo military camp about 200 kilometers (124 miles) from the capital, Bujumbura.

    Baratuza says Karashira was in charge of intelligence at the military camp and was killed while on patrol.

    Burundi accuses Rwanda of backing rebels opposed to Nkurunziza, charges that Rwanda denies.